Banyan Manor

We really enjoyed our stay at Banyan Manor! The property was beautifully maintained, very clean, and perfect for our group of families. The interior was very updated and was really nice that every bedroom had its own bathroom. The location was ideal; only 2 blocks to the beach and a couple blocks from Pine Ave with restaurants, coffee shops, and shopping. We had a few minor maintenance issues come up during our stay and management was extremely responsive in getting those items taken care of for us which was appreciated. The only negatives were lack of kitchen supplies for cooking (ie no salt/pepper/oil, etc) which usually come stocked in other properties we have stayed at. In addition, we had landscapers and pool cleaners show up during our stay with no warning. A heads up would have been appreciated as we were using the backyard space and pool during these visits. Overall, we enjoyed our stay and would recommend Banyan Manor to others visiting AMI!

Melissa - Posted: 11/15/2025

Hi, Melissa, thank you so much for staying with us at Banyan Manor. We are thrilled to hear the home was a great fit for your families with its clean, updated interior and those private bathrooms in every bedroom. The location really is hard to beat with the beach and Pine Ave just a short stroll away. We appreciate you mentioning the minor maintenance items and are glad our team was able to jump on them quickly. Thank you as well for the notes on kitchen basics and advance notice for yard and pool service. There are items we do not provide, but guests can provide for themselves during their stays. We will share that with our operations team. We are happy you enjoyed your time here and truly appreciate the recommendation. We hope to welcome you back to AMI soon with Anna Maria Island Accommodations!!

Anna Maria Paradise staff

We enjoyed our stay at AMI rentals. It was extremely gorgeous and well stocked with everything we needed. The only downfall was the handrail on the stairs was broken which was a safety concern for our older guests and we had some issues with the water pressure and temperature. Otherwise was very clean and just as listed!

Hannah - Posted: 8/29/2025

Thanks for sharing your feedback, Hannah! We’re glad you found the home gorgeous, well-stocked, and just as listed. We’ll be sure to look into the handrail and water pressure, so it’s all set for future guests. Appreciate you staying with Anna Maria Island Accommodations, and we hope to welcome you back soon!

Anna Maria Paradise staff

We really enjoyed our stay. Beautiful home, decor, location…everything was amazing.

Susan - Posted: 8/5/2025

Hi, Susan, thank you so much for the wonderful review! We are thrilled to hear that you had such an amazing experience during your stay. Your kind words mean a lot to us, and we truly appreciate you taking the time to share your feedback. We hope to have the opportunity to welcome you back again in the future!!

Anna Maria Paradise staff

Very quiet neighborhood. The backyard was very tranquil to come back to after exploring the city. The host was very easy to communicate with and very informative. Wish we had more time to stay. Recommended and will probably rebook when we come back. Loved it!!!!

Justin - Posted: 6/13/2025

Incredible, love it!

Justin - Posted: 6/13/2025

What a perfect set up for 2 families of four. There is plenty of space and so much to do on site that everyone staed entertained. We enjoyed the swimming pool, the pool table, and fishing off the dock. The dock gave us the opportunity to rent a pontoon for several days with a place to tie up overnight. The kitchen is well stocked. The house came with 6 beach chairs, an ice chest, and a wagon to make the 4 minute walk to the beach even easier.

Elizabeth - Posted: 3/30/2025

Thank you for choosing us for your recent stay! Every review and every star you give us makes a huge difference to our success. If you enjoyed your stay, we'd love your 5-star review! We hope to host you again in the future!

Anna Maria Paradise staff

I, along with my daughters and their family, had a very relaxing and comfortable stay at Banyan Manor. It's super easy to get to the beach and to great restaurants. I would highly recommend staying here and I hope to in the future!

Timothy - Posted: 12/16/2024

Canal location and pool and outdoor common areas make the whole property. Just stunning - we rented late je and enjoyed paddling right off the canal dock.

Katherine B. - Posted: 9/23/2024

Thank you for your kind words! We’re thrilled you enjoyed the stunning canal location and the pool and outdoor spaces—they really do create a special atmosphere. Paddling right off the canal dock sounds like such a memorable experience! We’re so glad the property offered everything you needed for a wonderful stay, and we hope to welcome you back again soon for more adventures.

Anna Maria Paradise staff

it was a great house for our family and great location!! Thank you!

Lisa R. - Posted: 8/25/2024

Thank you for your review!

Anna Maria Paradise staff

Great house. Private and on a canal that you can bring a boat up to. Walkable to the beach (less than 5 min walk). Good amount of parking compared to other homes.

Rachel - Posted: 8/6/2024

My family and I enjoyed this property quite a bit on our last vacation. We were there with 4 adults and 3 young kids and everyone had plenty of room. The pool was the perfect size for long days of swimming. Plus the outdoor spaces were wonderful for relaxing adults. The house is a short walk to the beach. When we were there, the house had 4 beach chairs to use. The kitchen is well stocked for a rental with plenty of tools for cooking and dinnerware. It lives up to its pictures for sure!

Paige P. - Posted: 5/12/2024

Paige, we're thrilled to hear that you and your family enjoyed our property so much during your vacation! It's wonderful that everyone had plenty of room and that the pool was the perfect size for long days of swimming. We're delighted that the outdoor spaces provided a relaxing retreat for the adults, and that the short walk to the beach made it convenient to enjoy the sand and surf. We're glad you found the kitchen well stocked for cooking and that the house lived up to its pictures. Thank you for sharing your positive experience, and we hope to have the pleasure of hosting you and your family again for another memorable vacation in the future!

Anna Maria Paradise staff

What a great space and great location!

Kathryn - Posted: 4/25/2024

Kathryn, thank you for your feedback! We're thrilled to hear that you enjoyed our space and found the location to be great. If there's anything we can do to make your next stay even better, please don't hesitate to let us know. We hope to welcome you back again soon!

Anna Maria Paradise staff

We loved our stay at Banyan Manor. It was so beautiful, just like the pictures. We all agreed it was the best place we have rented. The pool area was amazing. We rented a golf cart from zoom around, they deliver to the house ( free with the code from the welcome email from Banyan Manor. We used Instacart to deliver groceries from Publix. The home has 4 beach chairs, umbrella, beach tent cover, two floating tubes and fishing poles for the canal. We had breakfast at Northshore cafe everyday and our favorite restaurants were Sandbar for lunch and waterfront for dinner. This home was incredible!!

Ingrid B. - Posted: 10/22/2023

Thank you for taking the time to share your wonderful experience, Ingrid. We are glad you enjoyed the home, pool, and convenient location. You were terrific guests, and we hope to welcome you back soon!

Anna Maria Paradise staff

We thoroughly enjoyed our stay at the Banyan house in AMI. It lives up to the pictures and it’s a great location. The house and pool area are awesome and we would definitely come back again. It’s close to the beach and restaurants.

PJ K. - Posted: 10/16/2023

Thank you for taking the time to share your wonderful experience, PJ. We are glad you enjoyed your stay and hope to welcome you back soon!

Anna Maria Paradise staff

This house was perfectly suited for our family! Everyone had their own suite and the outside space was amazing!

Jennifer F. - Posted: 8/2/2023

Thank you for allowing us to host you, Jennifer. We are glad you enjoyed your stay and hope to welcome you back soon!

Anna Maria Paradise staff

This is a very desirable home with new construction and modern features and amenities. It features plenty of inviting outdoor space with multiple seating areas centered around a pool and hut tub; this includes a pool table & ping pong table. Plenty of space and privacy. The home is on a canal with boat access, and about 2 blocks to beach access. Upon booking, guests will be directed to a local property management company, which was organized and responsive. This includes a separate rental agreement to sign, scan and return, which was reasonable and customary. We will definitely favor this home for our repeat visits to Anna Maria. Highly recommend!

Barrett B. - Posted: 6/11/2023

Thank you for taking the time to share your wonderful experience with us, Barrett. We are glad you enjoyed your stay and hope to welcome you back again soon!

Anna Maria Paradise staff

Very clean and all we dreamed of. Thank you

Darrell G. - Posted: 2/12/2023

Darrell, we are glad you enjoyed your stay and hope to host you again soon!

Anna Maria Paradise staff

We were a group of 4 couples and really enjoyed our stay. Location to the beach, town of AMI is excellent. We could walk easily to both. The house, kitchen is well equipped and has a beautiful pool and outside area. The management company is very responsive to any requests.

Megan S., Great Falls, Va - Posted: 2/8/2023

Megan, thank you for taking the time to share your experience with us. We are glad you enjoyed the home, kitchen, pool, location, and communication with our team. We hope to have the opportunity to host you again!

Anna Maria Paradise staff

Our two families (two children each) waited until the last minute to be sure our plans for Banyan Manor were still a GO after the island's brush with Ian roughly 9 days earlier. Other than a quickly addressed pool issue likely related to the storm, it was all pretty perfect. The entire property is as beautiful as the pics, if not more so. The property mgmt. company was very attentive, and we all enjoyed our first time on Anna Maria Island.

Kerry H. - Posted: 10/31/2022

Kerry, thank you for taking the time to share your experience with us. We are happy to hear you enjoyed your stay, and we hope to host you again soon!

Anna Maria Paradise staff

Worth every penny! We loved our stay! This is a great home for a family vacation. The home is beautiful. The decor is breath taking. Plenty to do outside, play by the pool, grill, and we even parked our boat out back in the canal. A bonus is the comfy beds! The beds are SO comfortable! The house is supplied with everything you need. Gorgeous home!! NO complaints! We will definitely be coming back!

Andréw - Posted: 8/21/2022

Hi Andrew, thanks for taking the time to share your experience with us here on the island. We hope to host you again soon!

Prime Vacations

Anna Maria Paradise staff

If you’re looking for an easy, laidback, family friendly vacation home then this is the place. AMI Accommodations made the booking process easy. During their courtesy call they suggested restaurants and activities that my family loved. Anna Maria island is easy to navigate and my kids enjoyed riding taking the golf cart everywhere. This home has a fantastic pool and plenty of outdoor space to kick back. Will definitely rent again next year!

Justin M. - Posted: 6/28/2022

Thank you for staying with us, Justin! We are so happy to hear that you had such a great experience. We look forward to hosting you again!

Anna Maria Paradise staff

Fantastic property.
Great location and accommodations exceeded our expectations.

Dave - Posted: 4/12/2022

Great place, great location! We loved everything about it. It was a short walk over to a fantastic beach, but we also could just spend hours in the pool and just hanging around the house.

Daniel - Posted: 3/24/2022

The perfect house and location. Everything was top notch and beautiful. Looking forward to booking again.

Mollie E. - Posted: 3/4/2022

Thank you Mollie for your recent stay here at our Banyan Manor property! We are happy to hear you had a wonderful stay. It was a pleasure hosting you and we invite you back anytime you need another island escape!

Anna Maria Paradise staff

This was our first time to anna maria and this house made the trip! So close to all the shops and restaurants. The beach was right down the road and my little ones loved fishing off the dock. The house was absolutely beautiful and the pool was the perfect size! We will definitely visit again!

Camry c. - Posted: 2/26/2022

Camry, we are so thankful for your recent stay and happy to hear this was your first island experience & that we got to be apart of it!! Your kind feedback means everything to us. You and your family were wonderful to host and we look forward to your next island stay.

Anna Maria Paradise staff

Had a reunion with some High School friends and this was the perfect property! Great for entertaining with the big open feel of the great room. Bedroom layout was perfect as well which allowed privacy. In a great location as well as its walking distance to restaurants and Pine Street. Only negative if you don't have kids is the pool alarms on all the doors. In the great room there are massive sliding doors that allow you to open them up and allow the nice breeze to come in but with the alarms you technically cannot keep them open for more than 15 seconds before an ear piercing alarm goes off. Lets just say there is a work around but you have to work hard. Hint: they are battery operated. See the need if you have little ones but we were all adults. Overall AMZING property. Still smelled like a new house.

Doug J. - Posted: 11/13/2021

Thank you for a great time! The house, amenities and ease of checking in and out made the stay extremely enjoyable. Thanks!

Nick L. - Posted: 7/11/2021

Nick, Thank you for your kind review on the magnificent Banyan Manor! We are so very glad to hear that you had a great time. Banyan Manor awaits your next visit, as do we! Regards, Anna Maria Island Accommodations Team

Anna Maria Paradise staff

My family really enjoyed their time at this property. AMI Locals is also a wonderful group to deal with too! Thanks for the perfect time Property Owners & AMI Locals Best, Queen Family

Christopher Q. - Posted: 6/1/2021

What a great house. Fantastic layout. Awesome outdoor spaces. Right spot in the island. Kids loved it. Guests were impressed with how nice the house was. Super stay!

Verified traveler - Posted: 4/16/2021

This brand new property is perfect! The design is so well-appointed throughout from the furniture, the layout, the artwork, finishes, kitchen, etc. Being that everything is brand new, that adds to the luxury. The outdoor space by pool and canal side is really nice. There is plenty of furniture whether you want to lay by the pool, read in a lounger, watch TV or play a game of pool in the shaded space, or BBQ and dine which is also shaded. The pool and hot tub get nice sun all day. Location is convenient to the Pine Avenue shops, Anna Maria pier, a few restaurants and the beach. We highly recommend a golf cart to get around. The island is VERY busy. We ended up eating at the house for almost every meal as the restaurants had 2-4 hour waits. The house layout was great for our family with the master on one side of the living and kitchen areas and three bedrooms on the other. However, it is still all close enough if you had younger children. All bedrooms have nice bathrooms, closets and towels. We did not need to reach out to the property manager for anything but email communication for check in/out was efficient. The ONLY drawback to the house is the security alarm on every door. It is piercingly loud. You have to press a bypass button every time you go out. It's not a big deal, but if you forget, it's a jolt to your system! It is so loud, we heard the neighbors one day next door yell, "what is that obnoxious noise over there?!" We were able to get used to it fairly quickly, but if your hands are full or you need more than 10 seconds to get out the door, be prepared. As pool owners, we understand and appreciate knowing when someone is coming and going out the door, but there should be a disable and waiver signing option for families with older children. Despite this small issue, we would ABSOLUTELY stay at this property again. It is stunningly beautiful on a charming island.

Teresa R., Omaha - Posted: 4/3/2021

The house is absolutely beautiful, comfortable and extremely well appointed. The property manager was great...helpful, and very responsive. The location is great, walking distance to the beach, town, area sites. We had a wonderful family gathering and would absolutely come back again.

Wendi W. - Posted: 2/9/2021