Casa Allegria

We loved the island and the location of the house—lots of potential. However, there were several things that made the stay less than enjoyable
Towels: only six extremely small bath towels were provided for six people—like hand towels. By the time you finished drying off, the towel was completely soaked
Kitchen basics: The kitchen had no basics for cooking. We had to buy everything, which we haven’t encountered at other Airbnbs. Even a few essentials—oil, vinegar, flour, herbs—would make a huge difference.
Kitchen ventilation: There’s no proper exhaust fan venting outside, so the smoke alarm went off repeatedly while cooking. It made it more stressful than needed
Grill propane was low and instead of replacing it before our arrival, we were left to handle it
The beach buggy had a flat tire. They brought a new wagon that was not ideal, instead of just bringing an air pump
The bed in one room, while nice and big, barely fit in the room and we hit our knees on the wooden frame several times

Ariana - Posted: 11/28/2025

Hi, Ariana, thank you for staying with us at Casa Allegria and for sharing such thoughtful feedback. We’re glad you loved the island and the location, and we’re truly sorry that several issues impacted your stay. We do provide starter kits for toiletries, paper goods, and basic supplies, and guests provide for themselves after they run out. Cooking items like oils, spices, and flour aren’t provided due to liability and food safety concerns. We also apologize for the maintenance concerns, including the beach buggy, grill propane, and ventilation frustrations. In the future, please reach out during your stay, our team lives and works on the island and is always ready to help immediately. Thank you again for your honesty. We hope to have the chance to welcome you back for a smoother, more enjoyable experience with Anna Maria Island Accommodations.

Anna Maria Paradise staff

Had an amazing stay!! Really appreciated the beach supplies being provided.Home is perfect.Great host and great home! Will definitely visit again.Thank you so much.

Nicole - Posted: 7/7/2025

Thank you so much for your amazing feedback! We're so happy to hear you had a great stay and appreciated the beach supplies — we love making those little touches count. It’s wonderful to know the home was perfect for you and that you felt well taken care of. We truly look forward to welcoming you back again soon!

Anna Maria Paradise staff

This property is amazing, has everything you need and is in a great location on the island. I highly recommend staying here and we will definitely be staying here on our next trip to the island.

Donna - Posted: 5/16/2025

Thank you for choosing us for your recent stay! Every review and every star you give us makes a huge difference to our success. If you enjoyed your stay, we'd love your 5-star review! We hope to host you again in the future!

Anna Maria Paradise staff

Our stay at Casa Allegria was wonderful! The house was incredibly clean!! Every space in the house was spotless. The space was perfect for my 3 kids (6, 4, 1), my husband, and myself. I loved the screened in area by the pool. We were able to eat dinner there without worrying about a kid roaming near the pool. The beach was a quick walk - no more than 5 minutes and then it was easy to come back and enjoy an afternoon at the pool. The backyard is big, private, and beautiful with trees and flowers. The house had everything we needed. It included more beach chairs than what was listed. The master bed was very comfortable. When we had a question, the property manager responded quickly. The house is also really close to Pine Ave where many of the the shops and restaurants are located. This house was perfect and I would love to stay there again!

Meghan - Posted: 4/27/2025

Thank you so much for the wonderful review of your stay at Casa Allegria. We are thrilled to hear that you and your family had a fantastic time and that the house exceeded your expectations. It's great to know that the cleanliness, amenities, and location of the property were all to your satisfaction. We truly appreciate your feedback and look forward to welcoming you back in the future.

Anna Maria Paradise staff

Great house in a great location, you feel right at home and are a short distance from enough to do and see to make a week fly by on no time, honestly such a great family destination.

Carlie - Posted: 8/15/2024

My family had a great week staying at this property. The bedrooms were comfortable and we had plenty of room. The pool was awesome and we spent most of our time in it. Highly recommend this rental!

Courtney B. - Posted: 7/7/2024

Casa Allegria was the perfect spot for our vacation. The kids loved the pool and the short walk to the beach. The home is very well-stocked with kitchen utensils, awesome grill, and plenty of beach supplies (chairs, tent, rolling cart, paddle games, etc.). Host communication is also top notch. I would give 6 stars if I could.

Gary P. - Posted: 5/19/2024

Gary, thank you for your glowing review! We're thrilled to hear that Casa Allegria was the perfect spot for your vacation. It's fantastic that the kids enjoyed the pool and the short walk to the beach. We're delighted that you found the home well-stocked with kitchen utensils, and that you appreciated the awesome grill and abundance of beach supplies. Providing top-notch communication is important to us, so we're glad to hear that we met your expectations in that regard. Your feedback means a lot to us, and we truly appreciate your kind words. We would love to welcome you back again in the future! If you have any questions or need assistance, don't hesitate to reach out.

Anna Maria Paradise staff

Myself, my husband, and our almost two year old daughter stayed here for 5 days. It was a great stay - the backyard is beautiful, the pool is heated and has a great ledge for young kids + an umbrella, and plenty of seating. The location also could not be beat - a block from beach access, and walking distance to plenty of restaurant and coffee shops. We had a great time and would stay again.

Dakota F. - Posted: 3/5/2024

Dakota, thank you so much for sharing your experience! We're thrilled to hear that you, your husband, and your daughter enjoyed your 5-day stay with us. It's fantastic to know that you found the backyard beautiful, the heated pool accommodating for your little one, and the location convenient with easy access to the beach and nearby dining options. We appreciate your kind words and hope to welcome you back for another wonderful stay in the future!

Anna Maria Paradise staff

It was our first trip to Anna Maria and we absolutely loved the house and everything about it. It was the perfect size for our group and had everything we needed and more. The only complaint we had was the dishwasher isn’t the greatest but we plan to come back and stay again. Perfect location. Highly recommend.

Nicole B. - Posted: 12/15/2023

Nicole, thank you for sharing your positive experience with us. We're delighted to hear that you loved the property and found it suitable for your group. We appreciate your feedback about the dishwasher, and we'll ensure that this is communicated to our team. If you have any specific suggestions or requests for your next stay, feel free to let us know. We look forward to welcoming you back for another enjoyable visit.

Anna Maria Paradise staff

Fabulous stay! This home was perfect for our family of 5. Super clean, had everything we needed for a fun week at the beach. We loved the pool area and short walk to the beach.

Angela S. - Posted: 8/27/2023

Thank you for taking the time to share your wonderful experience with us, Angela. We are glad you enjoyed your stay and hope to welcome you back soon!

Anna Maria Paradise staff

We had a wonderful time at Casa Allegria! Beautiful pool and backyard that was perfect for my family of 5. Very close walk to the beach- they had beach chairs, a beach blanket, and floaties for the pool. We rented a golf cart and went all around the island. Highly recommend.

Bree - Posted: 7/21/2023

Thank you for taking the time to share your wonderful experience with us, Bree. We are glad you enjoyed the home, pool, and convenient location. You were terrific guests, and we hope to welcome you back again soon!

Anna Maria Paradise staff

The house was nice, clean and have everyone you needed. The Island is beautiful and has everything you need on the Island. Great place to relax and is a really short walk to the beautiful beach!

Jamie W. - Posted: 5/20/2023

Thank you for allowing us to host you, Jamie. We are glad you enjoyed your stay and hope to welcome you back again soon!

Anna Maria Paradise staff

We felt as if we were a guest in someone's home and not just renting a property. Clean, spacious, location all excellent. The screened-in porch and pool area were wonderful. Put all of that under a bright blue sky, sun and warm temperatures - we were soooo sad to leave.

Lawrence M. - Posted: 3/1/2023

Lawrence, thank you so much for taking the time to share your experience. We are glad you and your family were comfortable and enjoyed your stay. We hope to have the opportunity to host you all again soon!

Anna Maria Paradise staff

This was the perfect location. Short walk to the beach and the house was darling. Plenty of things to do. I would say, make sure to bring your own toilet paper, paper towels, trash bags, and shampoo/conditioner/soap. Overall it was amazing! We truly had the best most relaxing time.

Jordan - Posted: 11/5/2022

Thank you for allowing us to host you, Jordan. We are happy to hear you enjoyed the home and were able to have a relaxing vacation. You were a wonderful guest, and we hope to welcome you back again soon!

Anna Maria Paradise staff

Everything went really smoothly with good communication. Not complaints..just preferences: more blankets. Like small ones for watching TV Better doorknobs with better locks. There are deadbolts on all outside doors, but things would feel more secure with better knobs. And curtains on windows not just the blinds.

Beccah W. - Posted: 8/13/2022

Beccah, we are thrilled to hear you enjoyed the home and location. We appreciate your feedback, and we'll be sure to pass everything along to our team and owners. Thank you.

Anna Maria Paradise staff

We had a great stay at Casa Alegria. It's less than a 5 minute work from a beautiful beach and the house had all we needed for a great trip. Pool was perfect for floating later in the day. Rounded out the day with some very competitive cornhole with the kids. Not only will we recommend this house, we will likely look for a trip back to it. Also need to give props to the property manager, AMI Accommodations, they did a great job.

Mark K. - Posted: 4/24/2022

House was even nicer than in the pictures! Impeccably clean, comfortable beds, lovely pool and literally 10 min walk to the beach. Would definitely stay again.

mounia t. - Posted: 5/30/2021

Cheerful, beauty and homey. One of the cleanest places we have every stayed. We felt at home. Kitchen was well equipped. Quiet dead-end street with friendly neighbors. Close to beach and trolley. Had minor issues that were addressed immediately and went beyond what we hoped or expected. Look forward to staying here again.

Susan W. - Posted: 11/12/2019

Thank you so kindly for your nice review of Casa Allegria. We’re pleased that you enjoyed the home and its close proximity to the beach and the trolley. Guest satisfaction is our main objective so we are glad to know that our team took care of the minor issues you experienced in a timely and professional manner. Thank you again, and we look forward to your return visit to Anna Maria Island.

Anna Maria Paradise staff

The layout of the house worked perfect for us. The grandparents took the master. At the other side of the house was the queen bed room and the two twins. There was a shared bathroom. The kids didn’t wake up the grandparents once. The pool isn’t large so more than two kids could be crowded. The queen bed was very uncomfortable, but not worth downgrading the rating.

D H. - Posted: 8/29/2019

Thank you so much for your five-star review of Casa Allegria. We’re pleased that the layout of the home worked so well for your multi-generation family vacation. Yours is the first mention of the bed being uncomfortable. We’ll get our team over to the home to investigate and make any necessary recommendations to the home’s owner. We appreciate your letting us know as guest comfort is our top priority . Thank you again for your feedback. We look forward to your next visit to Anna Maria Island.

Anna Maria Paradise staff

We had a great time during our vacation, the house was great really clean and enjoyable. We would stay again.

India p. - Posted: 7/8/2019

Awesome vacation with the family and planning to go back already.

Meriam V. - Posted: 8/11/2018

the furniture in the tv room was terrible they would need to update for me to stay again also they need to Clorox the master bath shower

ken c. - Posted: 2/10/2018

Convenient location for beach, restaurants and free trolley, kid friendly pool, and quiet area. Will definitely recommend to others!

LaJean S. - Posted: 7/15/2017