Seahorse Paradise

It was as advertised. Beautiful house, property managers were great. No real issues other than I wish we would have stayed longer.

Thomas - Posted: 11/13/2025

Hi, Thomas, thank you for staying with us at Seahorse Paradise. We’re so glad to hear the home was exactly as advertised and that our team helped make your stay smooth and enjoyable. It really is a beautiful spot for relaxing and soaking up island time. We wish you could have stayed longer too. We’d love to welcome you back soon with Anna Maria Island Accommodations!!

Anna Maria Paradise staff

Everything was exactly as described

Gary - Posted: 3/29/2024

Gary, thank you for your feedback! We're thrilled to hear that everything met your expectations and was as described. Providing accurate information and ensuring a seamless experience for our guests is important to us.
If you have any further comments or if there's anything else we can assist you with, please don't hesitate to reach out. We hope to have the opportunity to welcome you back in the future!

Anna Maria Paradise staff

This Wonderful Anna Maria beach house was perfectly located. It sits in a nice area close to all the islands amenities. The house was very well taken care of and it's beachy decorations added to the house's tropical feel. Its well Design backyard gave you a resort like experience and the pool delivered the winning touch.

Daniel H. - Posted: 8/7/2023

Thank you for taking the time to share your wonderful experience with us, Daniel. We are glad you enjoyed the home, pool, and backyard. You were terrific guests, and we hope to welcome you back soon!

Anna Maria Paradise staff

This property is centrally located, which makes it super easy to take a couple minute stroll down to the beach with a wagon full of chairs and drinks, or a short drive to the local restaurants or stores. Home has been nicely updated and won’t disappoint. Our kids loved playing in the pool and it was great having the shaded space and outdoor seating area.

Kent S. - Posted: 4/3/2023

Thank you for taking the time to share your experience with us, Kent. We are thrilled you enjoyed the home, pool, and convenient location. We hope to host you again in the future!

Anna Maria Paradise staff

Everything about this place was as advertised. The walk to the beach was short and we loved the pool.

Justin - Posted: 8/19/2022

Justin, we are happy to hear you enjoyed your stay and the pool. We hope to host you again sometime soon!

Anna Maria Paradise staff

Renting this property was very easy.

Renee O. - Posted: 4/21/2022

My family and I had a great time at seahorse paradise. The house was just as the pictures are. If I had to say anything negative about the house. I could only say that I wish we could have turned the thermostat down a couple of degrees. The house was a little warmer than we are used to. But I understand they are trying to keep the power bill under control. Other than that it was very pleasant.

Andrew N. - Posted: 9/4/2021

Andrew, Thank you for your review! We are happy that you enjoyed your stay. Please give us a call if there is anything we can do to make your stay more comfortable, we will try to assist as best as we can! We hope to see you again soon! Regards, Anna Maria Island Accommodations

Anna Maria Paradise staff

Enjoyed this nice property with the pool and outside area. The only downfall was the couch and loveseat. They were very worn out and uncomfortable with no support. Location was close to the beach, stores, restaurants, etc.

Christa S. - Posted: 8/22/2021

The listing was very accurate and provided a good representation of what we were renting. As our first time on AMI, friends had told us its a good idea to rent a golf cart to get around, and we're glad we did as it made it a little easier carting things to and from the beach and exploring other parts of the island. Would recommend this property!

Ryan S. - Posted: 4/29/2021

Everything was perfect

zulema b. - Posted: 9/5/2019

We visited Seahorse Paradise with our two boys, 4 & 8, along with our in-laws last week for spring break. The house was very clean, and nicely decorated. Between the indoor and outdoor space, we had plenty of room for everyone not to feel on top of each other. The boys enjoyed the pool every day! The beach was just a short 3 block walk, and was stunning. It was nice to decide whether to do the pool or the beach, or both in one day. It was also VERY nice to have the pool toys, beach cart, beach toys, beach chairs and towels.

Jennifer J. - Posted: 4/2/2019

Very nice home. Immaculately clean. Comfortable furniture and bed. Short walk to beach. Would recommend to friends or family.

Charles C., Savannah, Tan - Posted: 2/17/2019

Thank you for letting us know about your stay at Seahorse Paradise. Our team is always happy to hear that our guests had a comfortable and enjoyable stay. This is a beautiful home and we hope to have you stay with us again soon!

Anna Maria Paradise staff

The property was clean and comfortable! We loved the short walk to the beach and appreciated the wagon to bring all our stuff to the beach. I would recommend this lovely home to everyone. Thank you for sharing your home with us.

Doug H. - Posted: 3/11/2018

Everything about the house fit our needs perfectly.

Victor B. - Posted: 1/20/2018

This home was beautiful! Gorgeous pool and wonderful walk to the beach!

Laura S. - Posted: 5/14/2017

Rented this house for a week and couldn't of been happier. Excellent service, the house is located amongst the heart of AMI. renting next year for three weeks this time :)

heidi G., Duncan - Posted: 3/7/2017

Our family had the best time ever on this vacation. The Seahorse paradise is a beautiful spacious house! We loved the downstairs outdoor area and couldn't get enough of the pool! The walk to the beach was not too long. We can't wait to return to AnnaMaria Island and stay at the Seahorse Paradise!

Debbie G. - Posted: 7/12/2015

Seahorse Paradise is a great vacation house on Anna Maria Island. We visited for Memorial Day with another couple and all of our kids. The location is terrific as there is just a short walk to the beach (there is also beach parking at the end of 68th Street) and there are also nearby trolley stops. The house looks just like the pictures. It is well-appointed and the kids loved that they had their own space and, of course, a heated pool. We were able to cook when we wanted and to check out some of our favorite local eateries, like Poppo's and Two Scoops. I would definitely recommend Seahorse Paradise to any couples or families looking to enjoy some time on the island.

Anonymous - Posted: 10/3/2014

This has been our second time staying at Seahorse Paradise. We love the close proximity and straight shot to the beach and then being able to take a dip in the heated pool at the end of the day. The huge, covered outdoor living area is a nice luxury especially on a rainy day and love the short walk to one of our favorite dining spots where we got engaged at the Beach Bistro.

Anonymous - Posted: 6/5/2014