Silver King

I read another review that said this place is even more beautiful in person and that the photos don’t do it justice — and that couldn’t be more true. This is truly the most beautiful home and location I’ve ever stayed in.
If I could make one small suggestion, it would be to add a few beach umbrellas to go along with the chairs that are already provided in the basement. It would also be wonderful if beach and pool toys or floats could be kept for future guests to enjoy.

Janet - Posted: 10/15/2025

Thank you for sharing your experience with us, Janet. We’re thrilled to hear you found Silver King even more beautiful in person and that the home and location made such a great impression. We appreciate your thoughtful suggestions about adding beach umbrellas and toys. It’s wonderful to know you enjoyed your stay, and we hope to welcome you back for another visit soon!!

Anna Maria Paradise staff

Our stay at the Silver King was incredible. The house is stunning, walkable to restaurants and beaches, and has a ton to do on the property as well. This was the perfect introduction to Anna Maria Island for our family. We can’t wait to come back!!

Danielle - Posted: 4/27/2025

Thank you so much for the wonderful review of your stay at the Silver King. We are delighted to hear that you and your family had such an incredible time and that the property and its amenities were a perfect fit for your introduction to Anna Maria Island. We look forward to welcoming you back in the future and appreciate your kind words.

Anna Maria Paradise staff

This house was everything we were looking for. Highly recommended! Managing team made it very easy.

Jose - Posted: 7/13/2024

We love hearing that the house was everything you wanted. 💖 We’re so glad you had a fabulous stay! 🎉

Anna Maria Paradise staff

Amazing!!! Would highly recommended if you are considering booking rhis home. The ideal way to move around the island is by golf cart but this home is walkable to bean island for sunset, the City Pier, shops, ice cream & even the bait shop to catch fish right of the dock at this home. Everything you need is already at this home for youre convenience. The Pools is awesome! Going up to the top deck at night is a must for the view. Comfortable beds. No complaints at all my old regret is not staying longer.

Tim - Posted: 5/31/2024

Wow, thank you for the fantastic review, Tim! We agree, the top deck view is unbeatable at night. We'd love to have you back for a longer stay next time! 🌟

Anna Maria Paradise staff

Property was exactly as advertised. Kitchen was well stocked. Location was great, walked to restaurants and shops everyday. Internet and tv were not working and management followed up quickly yo get it fixed. I would suggest more bath towels. The boat lift on the dock was positioned low so we had to carefully tie our boat not to hit it. If it was raised up this could have been prevented. Overall lovely property and would stay again.

Candice D. - Posted: 4/23/2024

Candice, thank you for your detailed review of the property! We're glad to hear that it lived up to your expectations and that you found the kitchen well-stocked and the location convenient for your needs. We appreciate your feedback regarding the internet and TV issues and are pleased that our management team was able to promptly address them. Your suggestion for more bath towels is duly noted, and we'll work on improving that aspect for future guests. Additionally, we'll look into the positioning of the boat lift to ensure it's more convenient for our guests in the future. We're delighted that you found the property lovely overall and would be happy to welcome you back for another stay!

Anna Maria Paradise staff

we had a wonderful time, the location of the house was perfect very close to the beach, and local restaurants...the house, the pool and the canal were perfect we had a great time.

Angelica - Posted: 10/29/2023

Thank you for taking the time to share your wonderful experience, Angelica. We are glad you enjoyed the home, pool, and convenient location. You were terrific guests, and we hope to welcome you all back soon!

Anna Maria Paradise staff

Words won’t describe how much we love this place.
Our four toddler children loved this place along with pregnant wife and Nanny.
This home was super functional for us with so much other space available.
Honestly the pictures doesn’t do this home Justice to be honest. We’ll be back for sure. Thanks for the wonderful experience.

Justin - Posted: 5/14/2023

Thank you for taking the time to share your wonderful experience with us, Justin. We are thrilled your family enjoyed the home, and we look forward to hosting you all again in the future!

Anna Maria Paradise staff

Perfect location! Right in between the beach and pier. So close to Pine with all the shops. The house was so nice and clean. Plenty of room and nicer than the pictures showed.

Kristen - Posted: 4/30/2023

Thank you for allowing us to host you, Kristen. We are thrilled you enjoyed your stay, and we hope to welcome you back again soon!

Anna Maria Paradise staff

We had a wonderful experience- This house is much more beautiful in real life than the photos!! The location is on the prettier, quieter side of the island— The heater in the pool went out midway through our trip- the weather was cooler so we REALLY missed having a heated pool- BUT- the property managers stayed on top of the issue- communication was fantastic- (it was fixed our last day…). The heated pool breaking was not the fault of property management - and AMI locals were always ready to help. (Example- the first day we got there- I couldn’t figure out the tv remotes — I called- and 30 minutes later- someone was there and helped me through that- and Ta- dah- . working TVs. ! Super clean! This was by far the nicest VRBO I’d ever stayed at- considering the property, cleanliness, management, communication, amenities (although a FEW more basics would have been helpful …. Like including at least a single Washing machine detergent (one of our kids thew up the vry first night (motion sick from the flight) , and we weren’t able to do any laundry til the next morning) … but otherwise - amazing$

Winona H., Milwaukee, WI - Posted: 2/19/2022

This property is actually nicer than it is portrayed on websites. Clean, comfortable and lovely. Conveniently located. Dock, deck and rooftop lookout are only a few of the areas that make this property so appealing. Hopefully we will have the opportunity to return sometime soon.

Verified traveler - Posted: 10/22/2021

Amazing!

Elizabeth G. - Posted: 5/28/2021

This property was enjoyable to our group with plenty of space for everyone. We had a party of 7 with 5 kids which, of course, all needed their own space. We were surprised when we arrived and found the "4th level" sun deck. I am not sure if this was a new addition but it appeared to be. Great views from up there! We would come back again for sure.

Lake P. - Posted: 4/5/2021

Only suggestion is to have labels for all the light switches. In particular the one for the dock! Lol, seriously my only complaint.

Paul D. - Posted: 3/17/2021

House was very spacious. Family enjoyed the house and all amenities. We had noticed a problem with the washing machine what we thought to be unbalanced. However it was not, it had moved to the point we were unable to open the laundry room door. The realty company came and inspected at which point they had to intervene. Other than that slight problem we enjoyed everything about the property and location.

Carol W. - Posted: 8/30/2020

Hi Carol, Thank you for the great review and feedback. We are glad that our team could help you with the issue and that you still enjoyed the home and this beautiful island. We hope to see you again!

Anna Maria Paradise staff

Blue Turtle is spacious enough for you & family but also cozy. Close walking distance to beach & stores, yet away from hustle bustle. Pool area is awesome with landscaping to provide privacy, fun & relaxation. At the pool we swam, chatted, read books & took naps. We also took advantage of the dock to relax & read. We saw nature & boats & actually saw a manatee swim right by us! Beautiful creatures they are. Home is tastefully appointed with beach flair added. Next to the kitchen is tv sitting area where we watched a few movies together after beautiful day at beach & pool. Beach/pool chairs & floats appreciated to add to our beach/pool experience. We also used the grill several times to cook dinner at home. It's nice to float & relax while dinner is cooking! Large refrigerator for all our needs. The beds-SO COMFY! My family mentioned they never had such a good nice sleep away from home. Our trip included Memorial Day weekend. We took the short walk up to Anna Maria park to attend a service which included recognizing the branches of military service & sacrifices. Service included an orchestra which played military music pieces beautifully. Our family loves the island and staying at Blue Turtle added to our memorable family experience. Thank you for sharing your piece of paradise with us. We look forward to our next visit & making more family memories!

Penny Heinz F. - Posted: 6/17/2019

The house was lovely. Perfect for our family of 4. Walk to the beach and to the amazing donut store, The Donut Experience. No problems or issues at all. Loved it!

LISA R., Newtown Sq, PA - Posted: 4/27/2019

We're so glad that you enjoyed your stay with us at Blue Turtle. We hope to have you stay with us again for your future Anna Maria Island vacation needs!

Anna Maria Paradise staff

Beautiful house with a great location!! Our family had a wonderful time and we would all stay here again!

Amorette K. - Posted: 5/9/2018